In 1913 the brigantine Karluk, flagship of Vilhjalmur Stefansson’s Canadian Arctic Expedition, was beset in the ice of the Beaufort Sea while trying to reach a rendezvous at Herschel Island. The ship drifted helplessly for months and was crushed and sunk on 10–11 January 1914. Of the twenty-five people aboard, eleven died; fourteen survived. The survivors lived because the ship’s captain, the Newfoundland ice master Robert Bartlett, organized the abandoned party on the ice, marched most of it to Wrangel Island, and then walked some 700 miles across the frozen Chukchi Sea and Siberian coast with the Inuit hunter Kataktovik to summon rescue.
The disaster began with a decision by the expedition’s leader. Soon after the Karluk was beset in September 1913, Stefansson left the ship with a small party, stating he was going to hunt caribou, and did not return; the drifting ice carried the Karluk away, and Stefansson devoted himself to the expedition’s continental work, leaving the ship’s company under Bartlett. Whether his departure was a genuine hunt overtaken by the drift or an abandonment of a vessel he judged doomed has been argued ever since. Either way, the twenty-five people left aboard a ship he had chosen — an old, underpowered whaler poorly suited to heavy pack ice — were on their own.
The deaths came in clusters. Two parties that struck out independently across the ice after the sinking vanished or perished; later searches found remains of one group on Herald Island. Three more died on or near Wrangel Island, two of illness traced to spoiled rations and one in violent and never-explained circumstances. Bartlett’s trek brought help, and on 7 September 1914 the survivors were taken off Wrangel Island, including the Inuit family — the hunter Kuraluk, the seamstress Kiruk, and their two small daughters — whose hunting and skin-work were central to keeping the party alive.
In 1879 the U.S. Navy lieutenant George Washington De Long took the steam barque USS Jeannette north through the Bering Strait, chasing a theory that a warm Pacific current would open a navigable route to an ice-free sea at the top of the world. The theory was false. About 20 of the 33 men aboard died, including De Long himself. The ship was beset in the pack ice in September 1879, drifted helplessly for nearly two years, and was finally crushed and sunk north of Siberia on 13 June 1881. The survivors then hauled three boats and sledges south across the ice toward the Siberian mainland, were scattered by a gale off the Lena Delta, and died in ones and twos of cold and starvation in one of the most desolate corners of the Arctic.
The expedition was financed by James Gordon Bennett Jr., the proprietor of the New York Herald, the same press baron who had sent Stanley to find Livingstone. Its scientific premise came from the German geographer August Petermann, who held that the warm Kuro Siwo current flowed north through the Bering Strait and dissolved the polar ice into an “open polar sea.” Unknown to De Long, the U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey had already concluded the current had no such effect. The Jeannette sailed into the pack on the strength of a hypothesis that the available science had already refuted.
What the disaster produced, against the men’s intentions, was knowledge. De Long kept his journal almost to his death, and it was recovered from the snow of the Lena Delta the following spring, fixing the record of the party’s final weeks. And in 1884 wreckage from the Jeannette was found frozen into an ice floe off southwestern Greenland — on the far side of the Arctic — proving that a current carried ice clear across the polar sea from Siberia. That single observation inspired Fridtjof Nansen to design the Fram and deliberately freeze a ship into the same drift, turning the Jeannette‘s destruction into the foundation of a more successful method of polar travel.
In August 1914 Sir Ernest Shackleton sailed from England aboard the Endurance to attempt the first crossing of the Antarctic continent, from the Weddell Sea to the Ross Sea by way of the South Pole. The expedition never set foot on the route. Yet of the 28 men aboard Endurance, not one died. The ship was beset in the Weddell Sea pack ice in January 1915, drifted helplessly for ten months, was crushed, and sank on 21 November 1915. The men then survived for almost a year on the ice and the sea — camping on drifting floes, sailing three open boats to Elephant Island, and watching as Shackleton and five others crossed 1,300 kilometres of the Southern Ocean in a 6.9-metre lifeboat to fetch help. It is the archetypal survival epic, and it is included here not as a disaster but as the rare counter-case: the doomed expedition whose people were not doomed.
The crossing itself was a total failure. The Endurance never reached the Antarctic mainland; the South Pole was never approached; the continent was not crossed until 1958, by a different expedition. By any measure of stated objective the expedition achieved nothing it set out to do. What it achieved instead was the preservation of every life under conditions that had killed comparable parties outright — the men of Greely, of the Jeannette, of Franklin. The difference was not luck alone. It was a sustained, deliberate refusal to let the party fracture, hoard, despair or split, enforced by a leader whose single surviving objective, once the ship was gone, was that everyone come home.
This account does not extend to the expedition’s other half. Shackleton’s plan required a second ship, Aurora, to lay supply depots from the Ross Sea side for a crossing party that never came; that Ross Sea party lost three men and is recorded under its own case file. On the Weddell Sea side — the Endurance and her 28 — the toll was zero, and the relevant question is how.